November 12, 2013


For this post I will admit upfront I have eaten a pie(or slice) from each place listed. This would explain why the list is quite edited for I only wanted to suggest resources I have actually used. It is safe to say I like pie.

Have a pie suggested? Do share!

Pies I like in the Greenpoint/Williamsburg area:

Pie Corps:

Maple Pecan, Fig and Chocolate Truffle (My fav!) and apple Crumb with Rosemary Caramel are just a few of the offerings at this great pie shop that is nestled on Driggs Avenue in Greenpoint. Deadline for Thanksgiving is November 24th.

Pies and Thighs:

Up until last year (we moved) we always bought our pies at P &T’s. Delicious. Obsess. The Banana Cream brings back memories of my grandmother and the chocolate pecan makes my brother in- law hater of pecans eat his share of slices. Deadline is Monday of Thanksgiving week at the latest for Thanksgiving pies.

Blue Stove:

We have also bought pies here for the Holidays, it’s hard to resist the pies here, they are quite delish. The Pear Ginger Crisp is amazing and the Plum Crumble is frankly original-I never see plum pies in this neighborhood. Deadline for ordering is November 21st. 

December 19th is the deadline for Christmas, call for deadline for Thanksgiving.

Worth the drive:

Not in the Greenpoint/Williamsburg area but SO worth the drive/subway trip:

Four and Twenty Blackbirds

One Girl Cookies

On the cheap and not bad:


Trader Joes

Mail order Pies

My Sugar Pies

Grand Traverse Pie Company



Apple & Rosemary Pie via Saveur

Pear Pie via Bon Appetit





 Photo via Pie Corps

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.